REVIEW: 'Calavera P.I.' #1 by Marco Finnegan

Calavera P.I. #1

Writer: Marco Finnegan

Artist: Marco Finnegan

Publisher: Oni Press

Release Date: November 13, 2024

Cover Price: $4.99

SOMETIMES IT TAKES A DEAD MAN TO CRACK THE CASE! From the desk of rising star Marco Finnegan (Morning Star, Night People), walk the shadow-shrouded alleys of Hollywoodland to solve the mystery of Calavera-a newly resurrected private investigator whose first case is about to straddle the blood-soaked boundaries between the living and the dead . . .

In 1925, Juan Calavera died a hero. After a career spent outside the law defending the Chicano barrios where the police refused to operate, he earned a reputation for fearlessness . . . and a gunshot in the stomach. Now, five years later, on Dia de los Muertos, his restless spirit has been summoned from the grave to help a desperate former colleague unravel a kidnapping all too close to home. With only days to solve the case before he is called back to the underworld, can Calavera reveal the identity of the masked human trafficker known as La Fantasma before tragedy strikes again . . . and solve the mystery of his own murder in the process?

Score:

★★★1/2 (3.5/5)

Calavera P.I. stands out with its Mexican-American influence, centering on Juan Calavera, a Chicano detective resurrected on Dia De Los Muertos. Creator Finnegan aimed to highlight Calavera's "outsider status" to challenge traditional noir narratives, typically dominated by white protagonists. This unique lens enriches the story, weaving in cultural traditions that enhance its visual appeal and thematic depth. 

The book effectively blends supernatural elements with classic crime storytelling, allowing both aspects to flourish without overshadowing one another. The integration of Chicano culture and the lively setting of 1930s L.A. infuses the narrative with vibrancy and historical context.

Maria Valdez, Calavera's colleague and confidant, adds further complexity to the story. Her role is significant, not just as a potential love interest but as a driving force for social and political commentary. She becomes Juan's anchor and tie to the real world when catastrophe strikes. 

However, despite its strengths, there are concerns about the plot's familiarity and its ability to engage with broader traditions meaningfully. The first issue feels rushed because there's a lot of setup. With the premise explained and the stakes laid out, the story will have more room to breathe. Also, continuing to see the chemistry between Maria and Juan evolve under new circumstances will be one of the intriguing aspects. 

Overall, 'Calavera P.I.' combines representation with homage, offering a fresh take on the noir genre.